Dye-free candy and treats: what to look for on labels (US and Canada)
We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. How this works
Our quick picks
| Pick | Best for | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|
| Plant-based food colouring for home baking | Best for colouring icing and treats at home | Amazon.caAmazon.com |
| Freeze-dried fruit powder | Best for natural pink, red and purple | Amazon.caAmazon.com |
1. Plant-based food colouring for home bakingBest for colouring icing and treats at home
- What we like
- Lets you colour icing, cookies and homemade gummies yourself and see exactly what's in the bottle.
- Watch out for
- Read the ingredient list on the box. Check whether the colours are plant-based or synthetic; the words food colouring alone don't tell you.
If you bake for holiday parties, a set of plant-based colours is the easiest way to skip synthetic dyes in your own treats.
2. Freeze-dried fruit powderBest for natural pink, red and purple
- What we like
- Made from fruit, so the colour comes with fruit flavour. Check the ingredient list for added sugar or other ingredients.
- Watch out for
- It adds flavour as well as colour, and it still contains the fruit's natural sugar.
Stirring a little strawberry or raspberry powder into plain icing or yogurt adds pink colour without a bottle of dye.
Bright red gummies, blue candy canes and rainbow sprinkles usually get their colour from synthetic food dyes. Many parents in the US and Canada are now looking for treats without them, and the rules are changing fast, especially in the US. This guide explains how to spot synthetic dyes on a label, what’s changing, and how to find or make treats coloured with plant-based colours instead.
This is general information. Synthetic dyes aren’t one of the priority food allergens, but if you think your child reacts to a food colour, talk to your family doctor.
Why parents are checking for dyes
In the US, the FDA says that “most children have no adverse effects” from foods with colour additives, but that “some evidence suggests that certain children may be sensitive to them” (FDA). The FDA’s Food Advisory Committee concluded in 2011 that a link between certified colours and behaviour effects in children “had not been established,” and the agency says it continues to assess the science (FDA).
Even so, US policy is moving away from these dyes, and many candy makers are reformulating. Whatever your reason, the label is where you find the answer.
What’s changing in the US
- Red No. 3 is on its way out. In January 2025 the FDA revoked authorization for FD&C Red No. 3 in food under the Delaney Clause, a law that bars colour additives found to cause cancer in humans or animals. The data showed cancer in male lab rats exposed to high levels. Food makers have until January 15, 2027 to remove it, and the FDA has asked them to do it sooner (FDA).
- Six more dyes are being phased out voluntarily. In April 2025, HHS and the FDA said they would work with industry to eliminate Green No. 3, Red No. 40, Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6, Blue No. 1 and Blue No. 2 by the end of 2026 (FDA). This is an industry effort, not a ban, so timing depends on each company.
- Company pledges are tracked publicly. The FDA keeps a page tracking food company pledges. As of its October 16, 2026 update, it lists Mars as offering product options without certified colours starting in 2026 (complete), and Hershey as planning to eliminate certified colours from snacks by the end of 2027 (in progress) (FDA). Pledges can mean dye-free options, not every product, so keep reading labels.
- New plant-based colours are approved. In May 2025 the FDA approved galdieria extract blue (from algae), expanded uses of butterfly pea flower extract (blues, purples and greens) and calcium phosphate (white), all of which can be used in candy (FDA). In February 2026 it added beetroot red and expanded the use of spirulina extract (FDA).
What’s the situation in Canada
US decisions don’t automatically apply in Canada. Health Canada’s List of Permitted Food Colours, in its October 2025 version, still includes erythrosine (the colour called Red No. 3 in the US) and allura red (Red No. 40) (Health Canada). So the same brand of candy can have a different recipe on each side of the border. Always read the label on the package you actually bought.
How to read the label in the US
US labels must name each FDA-certified colour, either in full (FD&C Blue No. 1) or short form (Blue 1) (FDA). Look for:
- Red 40, Red 3
- Yellow 5, Yellow 6
- Blue 1, Blue 2
- Green 3
- The word “Lake” after a colour (for example, “Red 40 Lake”). The FDA defines lakes as insoluble pigments made by chemically reacting a water-soluble colour, so a lake still comes from the same certified dye (FDA, FDA)
Colours that are exempt from certification, such as annatto extract, dehydrated beets, caramel, beta-carotene and grape skin extract, can be listed together as “artificial colors” or “color added” (FDA). That’s confusing, because “artificial color” on a US label doesn’t always mean a synthetic dye. To know exactly which colours are in a US product, you may need to check the brand’s website or contact the company.
One exempt colour, carmine (or cochineal extract), must always be named on US labels because of potential allergic reactions in some people (FDA). It isn’t a synthetic dye, so a “dye-free” red candy may still contain it.
“No artificial colors” claims
Since February 2026, the FDA allows companies to say “no artificial colors” when a product has no petroleum-based colours, even if it contains colours from natural sources. Before that, the claim was generally only made when a product had no added colour at all (FDA). The claim is a useful shortcut, but the ingredient list is still the final word.
How to read the label in Canada
In Canada, food colours must be declared by their specific common names in the ingredient list, and the general word “colour” can’t be used on its own (CFIA). Canadian names are different from US names, which trips up a lot of parents. The CFIA’s table matches them up (CFIA):
| On a Canadian label | US name |
|---|---|
| Allura red | Red No. 40 |
| Erythrosine | Red No. 3 |
| Tartrazine | Yellow No. 5 |
| Sunset yellow FCF | Yellow No. 6 |
| Brilliant blue FCF | Blue No. 1 |
| Indigotine | Blue No. 2 |
| Fast green FCF | Green No. 3 |
Colours from plants are named too. Beet red and annatto are both on Health Canada’s list, and the CFIA’s own labelling examples include “concentrated black carrot juice (for colour)” (CFIA).
Quick label checklist
- Skip the front of the package and go straight to the ingredient list.
- Look for the colour names above, in US or Canadian form, and the word “Lake.”
- Check the version you’re holding. Fun-size, holiday and cross-border versions can have different recipes.
- Re-check products you buy often. With so many companies reformulating in 2026 and 2027, labels are changing.
Dye-free doesn’t mean low sugar
A dye-free gummy has the same sugar as one with dyes. If you’re cutting back on both, our guide on how to read a candy label explains sugar lines and allergen statements, and how much sugar kids should have puts the numbers in context.
Make colourful treats at home
Homemade treats let you control the colour. Fruit is the easiest place to start: our fruit juice gummies and strawberry fruit leather get their colour from the fruit itself. For icing on holiday cookies, like our less-sugar shortbread, try a little freeze-dried fruit powder or a plant-based colouring set.
Sources
- US Food and Drug Administration: Color additives questions and answers for consumers
- US Food and Drug Administration: Color additives information for consumers
- US Food and Drug Administration: FDA encourages food manufacturers to accelerate phasing out the use of FD&C Red No. 3
- US Food and Drug Administration: HHS, FDA to phase out petroleum-based synthetic dyes in nation’s food supply (April 22, 2025)
- US Food and Drug Administration: FDA approves three food colors from natural sources (May 9, 2025)
- US Food and Drug Administration: FDA takes new approach to “no artificial colors” claims (February 5, 2026)
- US Food and Drug Administration: Tracking food industry pledges to remove petroleum-based food dyes
- US Food and Drug Administration: Summary of color additives for use in the United States
- US Food and Drug Administration: Regulatory status of color additives: FD&C Blue No. 1
- Health Canada: List of permitted food colours
- Canadian Food Inspection Agency: Food additives (labelling requirements)
- Canadian Food Inspection Agency: List of ingredients and allergens
- Canadian Food Inspection Agency: Food colours